Why not to buy Honeycrisp apples?

When it comes to gardening and landscaping, it is important to carefully consider the plants and fruits we choose to grow. While Honeycrisp apples may be a popular choice for many, there are several reasons why one might reconsider buying them.

1. Susceptibility to diseases: Honeycrisp apples are highly susceptible to black rot, powdery mildew, and fire blight. These diseases can quickly spread and damage the apple tree, leading to reduced fruit production and poor overall health of the tree. Dealing with these diseases can be time-consuming and require the use of chemical treatments, which may not be desirable for those who prefer organic gardening practices.

2. Vulnerability to heat and sunburn: Honeycrisp apples are known to be sensitive to heat and sunburn. The thin skin of the fruit makes it more prone to damage from excessive heat and direct sunlight. This can lead to blemishes, discoloration, and even premature fruit drop. In regions with hot summers, it can be a challenge to provide adequate shade and protection for Honeycrisp apple trees.

3. Large fruit size: While some may see this as an advantage, the larger size of Honeycrisp apples can pose some challenges. In the early years of the tree’s growth, the fruit can become excessively large, which puts strain on the branches. This increases the risk of branch breakage, especially during heavy winds or storms. It may require additional support or pruning to prevent such damage.

4. Thin and easily punctured skin: Honeycrisp apples have thin skin that is easily punctured. This makes them more susceptible to bruising and damage during handling and transportation. If you are planning to sell or share your apples, this fragility may result in a higher percentage of damaged fruit, affecting their market value or quality.

5. Taste preferences: Taste is subjective, and while many people enjoy the crisp and juicy texture of Honeycrisp apples, others may find them overly sweet or lacking in tartness. It is always a good idea to try different apple varieties and determine your personal preferences before committing to a particular cultivar.

In my personal experience as a gardening enthusiast, I have encountered these challenges with Honeycrisp apples. I have seen trees affected by diseases, struggled to protect them from sunburn, and dealt with the delicate nature of their fruit. While they can be rewarding to grow when the conditions are right, it is important to consider these factors before deciding to buy Honeycrisp apple trees.

Photo of author

Caroline Bates

Caroline is a Miami-based landscaper who specializes in drought-tolerant landscapes. She is the mother of two young children and also enjoys writing for GreenPacks.org in her spare time. Caroline takes great pride in her work, and loves being able to share her knowledge with others through her writing.