The difference between New York asters and New England asters lies in their physical characteristics. New York asters are generally shorter plants with thin stems and smooth leaves. On the other hand, New England asters are taller and bushier, with thicker stems and hairy leaves. These distinctions in appearance can help gardeners identify which type of aster they have, although it’s worth noting that both varieties are hardy and can thrive in USDA zones 4 to 8.
Personal Experience:
I have had the pleasure of growing both New York asters and New England asters in my garden, and I must say that their contrasting features make for an interesting display. While New York asters tend to be more compact and delicate-looking, New England asters make a bold statement with their taller stature and fuller foliage.
Let’s delve further into the characteristics of each type:
1. New York Asters:
– Shorter plants: New York asters typically reach a height of around 1 to 2 feet, making them suitable for borders or front-of-bed plantings.
– Thin stems: These asters have slender stems that can sometimes require staking to prevent bending or breaking.
– Smooth leaves: The leaves of New York asters have a smooth texture, adding to their overall refined appearance.
– Flower heads: The flowers of New York asters are typically small and compact, forming dense clusters at the top of the stems. They come in various shades of purple, blue, pink, and white.
2. New England Asters:
– Taller and bushier plants: New England asters can reach heights of 3 to 6 feet, creating a more substantial presence in the garden. Their bushy nature makes them ideal for mid-border or back-of-bed plantings.
– Thick stems: These asters have sturdy, thick stems that are less likely to require staking. This attribute makes them well-suited for withstanding strong winds or heavy rain.
– Hairy leaves: Unlike the smooth leaves of New York asters, New England asters have leaves covered in fine hairs, giving them a slightly rougher texture.
– Flower heads: The flowers of New England asters are larger and more open compared to New York asters. They also come in a wider range of colors, including vibrant shades of purple, pink, blue, and white.
Although there are distinct differences between New York asters and New England asters, both varieties are known for their hardiness and ease of cultivation. They are reliable and resilient plants that can thrive in a range of growing conditions, from full sun to partial shade. Additionally, both types of asters attract pollinators like bees and butterflies, making them valuable additions to any garden or landscape.
While New York asters are shorter with thin stems and smooth leaves, New England asters are taller, bushier, and have thicker stems with hairy leaves. These variations in appearance add diversity and interest to the garden, but ultimately, both types of asters are equally resilient and easy to grow.
