Is it better to propagate ivy in water or soil?

When it comes to propagating ivy, there are two main methods you can use: water propagation or soil propagation. Both methods have their advantages, but they also have some differences that may sway your decision.

Water propagation is a popular method for propagating many plants, including ivy. It involves placing cuttings of the plant in a jar or vase filled with clean water and allowing them to develop roots. One advantage of water propagation is that it allows you to observe the root development process, which can be quite fascinating. You can see the roots growing and forming, which gives you a clear indication of when it’s time to transfer the cuttings into soil. This can be a helpful visual cue for beginners who are new to propagation.

Another advantage of water propagation is that it is a clean and easy method. You don’t have to worry about soil and the mess that comes with it. It also allows you to easily monitor the water level and change it when necessary. This can help prevent issues such as root rot, as you can ensure that the water remains clean and fresh.

On the other hand, soil propagation has its own benefits. When you propagate ivy in soil, you skip the step of transferring the cuttings from water to soil, which can be a delicate process. This reduces the risk of damaging the newly formed roots during the transplanting process. Additionally, when you propagate ivy in soil, the cuttings are immediately exposed to the environment they will eventually grow in. This can help them acclimate and adapt to the soil conditions more easily, leading to a smoother transition once they are potted up.

So, which method is better? It ultimately depends on your personal preference and the resources you have available. If you enjoy watching the root development process and want a clear visual indicator of when to pot up your ivy cuttings, water propagation may be the way to go. On the other hand, if you want to simplify the process and reduce the risk of transplant shock, soil propagation may be a better option.

In my personal experience, I have successfully propagated ivy using both methods. I have found that water propagation can be an exciting and educational process, especially for beginners. However, I have also had great success with soil propagation, as it allows the cuttings to establish themselves in their final growing medium from the start.

Ultimately, the most important factors for successful propagation are providing the right conditions such as adequate light, temperature, and humidity, regardless of the method you choose. With proper care and attention, you can enjoy watching your ivy cuttings thrive and grow into beautiful plants, whether you choose to propagate them in water or soil.

Photo of author

Caroline Bates

Caroline is a Miami-based landscaper who specializes in drought-tolerant landscapes. She is the mother of two young children and also enjoys writing for GreenPacks.org in her spare time. Caroline takes great pride in her work, and loves being able to share her knowledge with others through her writing.